FAQs

Am I able to stop in and buy a baked good?

Unfortunately not, Tasty Bakery is not a storefront bakery. Everything we make is pre ordered.

How far in advance do I need to place my order?

The earlier the better! Placing your order at least a month in advance would be ideal, but if its a slower month, sometimes we only need a weeks notice!

How much are your cakes?

Each cake is very different, the price starts out with how many servings you'll be needing, from there we will have to look at how much detail and time that will be put into making items such as fondant designs, flowers, figures, etc. The base pricing for buttercream cakes start at $4 per serving and fondant covered cakes at  $5 per serving.

When and where can I pick up my cake?

We are located at 5499 Saltsburg Road, Murrysville PA 15668. Pickups will vary Wednesday- Sunday based on the time of year. Please refer to your finalized order form for exact time!



Can I pay for my cake in full when I pick it up?

NO! Every single order will have to have at least a 50% down payment . We accept cash, card, Venmo, or checks. If wanting to mail a check deposit, note how far in advance you will need to send it to reach us in time. All checks can be made out to "Tasty Bakery"!

“Do you make Gluten Free cakes?”

Yes! Please refer to our menu to our gluten free options

“Are you a nut free bakery?”

We are NOT a nut free bakery, but since we are such a small scale bakery, we are able to do nut free items. We have done many in the past with very positive feedback after!

Do you make cookies?

Yes! We specialize in decorated shortbread cookies, and macarons right now! Decorated cookies start at $72/ dozen, and macarons start at $28/ dozen.

I've never had fondant what does it taste like?

Fondant is a form of icing that is very smooth and looks flawless on cakes, many designs that go onto cakes are made from fondant. To me, it tastes like a chewier version of a marshmallow. Some people hate it while others love it. If you're worried your guests won't like the taste but you love the look, it is very easy to peel off and eat around!

Do you deliver, if so how far?

Absolutely! We understand it can be very stressful delivering a cake, so leave it to us to make sure it gets there in one piece! As for distance, right now there is no limit, the furthest we  have driven a large cake was 3.5 hours away. The usual fee is $2.75 per mile to the destination. Please provide your address or Venue if wanting a delivery quote!

Am I able to get each tier a different flavor?

Yes! There is no additional cost to do more than one flavor- this goes for both wedding cakes and all other events! The only additional cost would be if you were to add a specially batter or filling to any of those tiers!

What's the best way to cut your cake?

There's more than one way! Watch the two videos below.

Catch Up With us on Instagram @TastyBakeryPA